Both Halloween and Christmas time are amazing times of year to go the parks are really awesome then, as for the parties MNSSHP is great but i havent heard amazing things MVMCP and I doesn't look to good, but if you want to go for Christmas and skip the MCMCP right after Christmas is a great time to go, there are crowds but it's all worth it, and if you go between December 23 ad January 3 you just have to stay for new years eve which is AMAZING! There is no MVMCP party around that time though but you can still see the candlelight processional, te Osborne lights, snow on main street, the Christmas parade and all the amazing decorations, plus like I said new years eve is amazing! The fireworks are awesome and it's like one huge party all day! So my vote goes for around Christmas time when MVMCP isn't around but the decorations are up and you can stay for new years but if you want to go for a party MNSSHP is great, you get to dress up and get candy(yes even the adults) plus the parade and fireworks are great! - nodell111  153.3 #37 2:02PM

We did MNSSHP last year and loved it!! This year doing MVMCP for the first time. I would say you should experience them both at least once, well worth the cost. Also, do your research and go when it isn't crowded. The closer you get to the holiday, the crazier it will be. - mrsincredible  401.9 #5 10:07PM

We have only gone to MNSSHP. I love Christmas time and would love to during that season to DW. But it hasn't worked out for us. So my vote is MNSSHP ... We all love it! It's a great time of year, the weather was great too. - JessiBelle22  77.8 #54 10:35PM

Been to both and we liked MNSSHP better and less people great weather and we could still swim! I had just my 4 yrd old girl and we went to the xmass Party this past dec she was 6 and she like the other better. Still fun but not as cool - cheekymouse  34.9 #90 12:18AM

Ya, Iam afraid Iam going to be no help either because both times of the years are awesome!! The Halloween party and parade are outstanding!! I have gone twice!! However Disney at Christmas time is spectacular too! We go in late September or for Christmas right after thanksgiving. 👍👍😃 - toogrumpy  101.1 #46 12:20PM

There are no little ones,except for my nephew. But we just want to know which one is best overall for everyone? If u could choose one,which one would u choose? :) - mickeynme  102.3 #45 9:57PM

So both are great and not to be missed?? Thats what i thought. Lol..I was trying to choose,but I don't think I can do it!! Such a tough decision. One per yr I guess. Lol. We usually go in the summer but have always wanted to try the holidays. We heard they do the holidays absolutely fantastic! - mickeynme  102.3 #45 10:15PM

I've only done MNSSHP & I've heard it's better than MVMCP. However, I really want to experience all of the other things that happen at WDW only Christmastime! Of course Halloween is also the time for the Epcot International Food & Wine Festival (awesome)! I'm with mrsincredible, at some point you need to experience them both! - CollegeDisneyKnowledgeGrad  391.0 #6 10:20PM

We've only done MVMCP, but we loved it! Everything was so festive and beautiful. Plus, there were almost no lines. Cast members weren't even making us get off, they'd just let us ride some of the rides again and again! - BagGal  150.4 #39 10:21PM

See,the problem is..obviously it would be too much to go at both times of yr. I mean,that's two vacations. Too expensive.lol. Unless we just escaped to Disney for like a wknd,but what's the fun of rushing a Disney vacation?? Lol..so I'm trying my best to choose which one to do first. Then we'll do the other party the following yr. Oh decisions decisions! If only all decisions were this fun tho:) lol - mickeynme  102.3 #45 10:29PM

Another thing that I heard was that Christmas can be filled to capacity. Our friend went on Christmas day, and they wouldn't let him and his family in because the park was filled. I have never heard of that before. That's crazy! Lol. Way too busy, so I was wondering if the whole holiday season there is like that? Is it really that crowded? - mickeynme  102.3 #45 10:37PM

I think Christmas is the best over all for everyone ! Both are great , but if I had to chose one , it's Christmas !!!! - skcanfield  349.4 #10 10:39PM

I've been to WDW at both times of the year and Halloween is less crowded. Christmas is really beautiful but it's really crowded. - Tinkerbell1265  369.9 #8 10:54PM

Thank u all for sharing what u think and for all the help! I really appreciate it. Thank u all SO much:-) - mickeynme  102.3 #45 11:58PM

First 2 weeks of Dec is best. - totfav  8.7 #217 12:17AM

We love and celebrate Christmas and have been to the parks during the holidays. WDW is gorgeous during that time of year with it's decorations and the Osborne Family Spectacle. You can watch the parade and the Candle light processional at Epcot without doing the mvmcp. We would love to do that one some day but we really enjoy trick or treating, checking out the rarely seen characters at MK during Halloween plus we take full advantage of dressing in costumes as a family. We find it to be a little bit more worth the admission price to do MNSSHP! - Jalex239  379.8 #7 12:44AM