5.8 #16392 (DL Qual #7481

Dec 27, 2012 7:56 PM  The Hub
Hi everyone...which Disney restaurant would you choose.. Napa Rose or Carthays Circle? And do you need advance reservations for them? Thanks! :)

I would personally choose Napa Rose. I looked at Carthay Circles menu and nothing looked all that great to me. I dined at the chefs counter at Napa Rose and it was very good. A reservation is definitely a good idea. Enjoy whichever you choose :) - Nicole  380.2 #590 8:18PM
Thank you :) The napa rose menu does look more appetizing! - lovetrustpixidust  5.8 #16392 8:31PM
That's a hard choice. Napa rose has superior food, yet the food at Carthay is fantastic yet the decor is more appealing to me because of the nostalgic feel to it. And Carthay has amazing house biscuits. No wait I meant outstanding. - madsdad  1868.2 #92 8:36PM
I know it is a hard choice! I want a nice dinner for my fiancรฉ and I... We have so much to celebrate I thought a dinner at one of these restaurants would be nice :) - lovetrustpixidust  5.8 #16392 8:42PM
Well if you can do the chefs counter at Napa rose that wins hands down. That is fantastic! - madsdad  1868.2 #92 8:48PM
Thank you so much for your suggestion! I think I will see if they have any reservations:) - lovetrustpixidust  5.8 #16392 9:03PM
Madsdad knows his food! ;) I agree with him. - SueBayou  2019.0 #78 9:15PM
I still need to go to Carthay and try these biscuits! - KissDclown  1089.1 #167 9:15PM
Kiss! You must try the biscuits!!!! - madsdad  1868.2 #92 9:15PM
I concur with madsdad on this one. - EpicDio  460.3 #473 9:16PM
Haha I will! One of these days haha - KissDclown  1089.1 #167 9:33PM
The food at Carthay is no where in comparison to Napa Rose. Same with the service. The biscuits are good but I would take the house bread basket over the biscuits because of the variety and quantity - Dave   13493.0 #2 9:35PM
I must try these biscuits you speak of :) - lovetrustpixidust  5.8 #16392 9:36PM
The Chef's Counter at Napa Rose is fantastic - the food is indescribable and the experience is unforgettable. If it is within your budget, I would do Chef's Counter or Napa Rose, in general. You will not be disappointed. - EpicDio  460.3 #473 9:42PM
Carthay is Park food...The head Chef Andrew Sutton has really had his work cut out for him on getting this place in order with what he has and some things are good but its in no comparison to the food quality, unique dining choices and level of culinary experience that you will find at Napa Rose...The menu is unique at both places however you will find that if you are looking for a finer dining experience and have an adventurous palate, Napa Rose is your place...The menu changes on a weekly basis and is made from the freshest seasonal ingredients and cooked to perfection...There is a reason why its ranked each year at the top of all lists of Restaurants in Orange County - Dave  13493.0 #2 9:42PM
The foodie expert has spoken - PinkElephants  745.7 #259 9:51PM
same goes for Club 33. Based on food alone, the food at Napa Rose is WAY better than the Club - Dave   13493.0 #2 9:58PM
Thank you for this suggestion... My fiancรฉ and I are looking for something more fancy than park food... I think napa rose would be our best choice! It sounds amazing! We are celebrating our upcoming wedding and my graduation in 2013 :) - lovetrustpixidust  5.8 #16392 10:01PM
Good luck and congratulations! - EpicDio  460.3 #473 10:16PM
Thank you! - lovetrustpixidust  5.8 #16392 10:19PM
I have yet to get to Carthay but I will tell you that my experience at Napa Rose lived up to the expectation and will be the top of my Disney dining experiences, at least until the day I get to ride the 33 elevator up to the lunch buffet and live the dream! - cynDOLEwhip  1175.5 #148 10:16PM
Thank you all for the wonderful suggestions! I really appreciate all of your input! I'm going to try to get a reservation for Napa Rose chefs counter! It's sounds perfect for our celebration! - lovetrustpixidust  5.8 #16392 10:04PM
I think you've made a great choice! Have fun! - Spoonful_O_Sugar  613.1 #331 10:05PM
Thank you spoonful :) - lovetrustpixidust  5.8 #16392 10:07PM

Your Donations Help Us Make MouseWait Better!

TOP MWs of the WEEK

1.Melody_CM 730.67 #3  
2.Mouse4life 386.45 #100  
3.Winnie111286 247.07 #4  
4.OhanaPhoto 223.45 #24  
5.drummerkidd 146.03 #533  
6.shootanyangle 90.53 #2754  
7.happiestplace 89.89 #1105  
8.jeffandkaarina 74.13 #4058  
9.redsoxcarlos 72.08 #58  
10.Taunton 68.05 #190  

MW Quality Top 100    Monthly Leaders   Top 100 MouseRank Leaders  Top 50 News  Monthly Wait Time Leaders

Use this link to do your shopping on Amazon.com and MouseWait benefits from your purchases!

Get Disneyland and MouseWait News before anyone else! Join our Priority Text List today.

By UsernameBy Keyword
See what's happening LIVE at Disneyland!