He talked back to Cotton's parrot. - LaneSparrow316
846.9 #108 12:24PM
It got too close to the sword that his hand is touching. - KylaShea
533.2 #214 12:25PM
It's under the scabbard, maybe? lol - Donaldfan_532
226.0 #1291 12:25PM
Maybe he lost it at sea LOL - bibbity-bobbity
127.6 #2610 12:26PM
"Arrr, lost this here pinky in the battle against the trolls. Mighty tough they were, out fer blood they were. But I showed those scalawags exactly who they be dealin' with, arrrr." - CM_LionGeek
340.3 #431 12:27PM
"Look what a cannonball did to me hand!" - ladylikesdisney
921.5 #95 12:42PM
If this is supposed to be a clever play on a scene from muppet treasure island then well done Madame. If its not....I just made it that way in my head lol - lostgirl7988 541.5 #208 12:50PM
He wanted to become an assassin but cut off the wrong finger. - TheNewTrent
514.5 #228 12:45PM